Best Omnivore Alternatives for Reading Later
The recent shutdown of Omnivore has left many users searching for a new place for their curated reading lists and annotations. With the November 2024 deadline for data export approaching, it's crucial to explore alternative read-it-later apps now.
Whether you're a casual reader or a power user who heavily relies on features like highlighting and AI-powered organization, this guide will help you find the perfect replacement for Omnivore.
Understanding Omnivore and Its Shutdown
Overview of Omnivore
Omnivore was a versatile read-it-later service combining smart bookmarking with powerful AI-driven features. It stood out for its cross-platform compatibility, comprehensive article clipping, and offline reading. Users appreciated its AI-powered article recommendations and customizable reading preferences. This made it popular among digital readers who valued intelligent content organization.
Announcement of Shutdown
On October 29, 2024, Omnivore announced its closure following acquisition by ElevenLabs. The decision was driven by rising operational costs, marking a significant shift in the read-it-later app landscape. Users have until November 30, 2024, to export their data, including saved links, highlights, folders, and personal information.
After this deadline, all user data will be erased from Omnivore's servers. However, the Omnivore team isn't disappearing—they're joining ElevenLabs to develop ElevenReader, a specialized text-to-speech reader app. For those interested in maintaining their current setup, Omnivore's source code will remain open-source, allowing for self-hosting options.
Alternatives to Omnivore
Features and Pricing
Pocket offers a robust free plan with essential features like offline reading and tag organization. The premium version, at $4.99 monthly or $44.99 annually, includes full-text search and permanent article backup. One standout feature is its high-quality text-to-speech functionality, making it ideal for users who prefer audio consumption.
Pros and Cons
The platform excels with its flexible tag organization system and comprehensive free version. However, some users might find the interface somewhat cluttered, and the limited font options can be frustrating.
Readwise Reader
Features and Pricing
Readwise Reader is a comprehensive reading platform that goes beyond simple read-later functionality. Starting at $9.99 per month (billed annually) or $12.99 monthly after a 30-day free trial, it offers an extensive suite of features integrated within the broader Readwise ecosystem.
The platform excels in several key areas:
- Content Management: Unified reading experience for articles, newsletters, PDFs, EPUBs, tweets, and YouTube videos, all in one customizable interface
- Advanced Highlighting System: Unlimited highlighting capabilities across all content types, including images and video transcripts
- AI-Powered Features: The Ghostreader AI assistant can summarize content, define terms, and generate discussion questions
- Seamless Integration: Works with popular note-taking apps like Notion, Obsidian, and Roam Research
- Knowledge Retention: Leverages Readwise's spaced repetition system through daily review emails
- Cross-Platform Sync: Available on web, iOS, and Android with offline access
The platform integrates deeply with the core Readwise service, providing a complete system for both content consumption and knowledge retention.
While the platform offers powerful features, potential users should consider:
Pros:
- Comprehensive highlight management across all content types
- Rich customization options for reading experience
- AI-powered features enhance comprehension
- Seamless sync with popular note-taking tools
Cons:
- Higher price point compared to basic read-later apps
- Initial learning curve to master all features
- Some users express privacy concerns regarding AI features
- Requires ongoing subscription for access to saved content
Instapaper
Features and Pricing
Instapaper combines essential features like folder organization and highlighting with advanced capabilities such as speed reading. The premium plan, at $6 monthly or $50 yearly, provides additional features while maintaining a more affordable price point than some competitors.
Pros and Cons
The platform's strength lies in its robust note-taking features and speed reading functionality. However, free users face significant limitations, particularly with search capabilities. The folder system has a drawback where archived articles disappear from folders.
Raindrop
Features and Pricing
Raindrop distinguishes itself with AI-powered organization and extensive integration capabilities, connecting with over 2000 apps. The pro version is priced at $3 monthly or $28 annually, offering advanced features beyond the capable free tier.
Pros and Cons
Users appreciate Raindrop's intuitive interface and multiple view options, making it effective for team collaboration. The main drawbacks include limited offline access and occasional performance issues.
Safari Reading List
Features and Pricing
Safari Reading List comes free with Apple devices. It offers basic but essential features like offline reading, reader mode, and cross-device syncing within the Apple ecosystem. Its integration with Safari makes it a convenient choice for Apple users.
Pros and Cons
Seamless integration with Safari and straightforward usage are major advantages. However, it is exclusively available for Apple devices and offers limited organization options compared to dedicated read-it-later apps.
If you're interested in maximizing your productivity with Apple devices, check out our guide on integrating Notion with Apple Shortcuts.
Matter
Features and Pricing
Matter emphasizes AI integration and cross-platform support, with a free plan and a pro tier starting at $8 monthly. Specific feature details are limited, but the platform focuses on providing a modern reading experience enhanced by artificial intelligence.
Pros and Cons
The platform's AI capabilities set it apart. However, detailed information about its specific advantages and disadvantages is currently limited.
There is no quality open-source read-it-later app yet
While Omnivore's source code remains available for self-hosting, the current landscape lacks a comprehensive open-source alternative that matches the functionality of commercial options. This gap presents both a challenge and an opportunity for the open-source community to develop a robust solution.
Want to supercharge your productivity?
Unlock the full potential of Notion & Obsidian with our plugins.
Migration Guides from Omnivore
Exporting Data from Omnivore
With Omnivore shutting down on November 30, 2024, users need to export their data before it's erased. The platform will support data exports through this deadline, allowing users to preserve links, highlights, folders, and personal information. Users should monitor Omnivore's official communications for detailed export procedures as the deadline approaches.
Importing Data
Both Readwise Reader and Instapaper have created dedicated import tools specifically for Omnivore users to easily transfer their libraries.
Several read-it-later services have created tools to ease the transition from Omnivore. For example, Readwise Reader has a dedicated import tool specifically designed for Omnivore archives. This ensures a smooth transfer of your reading library. Instapaper has also launched an Omnivore importer that preserves articles and their associated data.
These specialized import tools significantly reduce the friction of switching platforms. This makes it easier for users to maintain their curated reading collections. When choosing a new platform, consider not just its features but also how well it can preserve your existing Omnivore data through its import process.
Recommendations Based on User Needs
Best Alternative for Casual Users
For readers who primarily save articles for later reading without complex organization needs, Safari Reading List offers the simplest solution for Apple users. However, Pocket is a more versatile choice for casual users across all platforms. Its intuitive interface and generous free tier make it accessible. The straightforward tag system and excellent text-to-speech functionality provide useful features without overwhelming users.
Best Alternative for Power Users
Readwise Reader stands out as the best choice for power users who rely on highlighting and note-taking features. Its spaced repetition system and deep integration with note-taking apps make it perfect for researchers, writers, and knowledge workers. The platform's daily email review system keeps users engaged with their saved content, and its comprehensive search capabilities allow for efficient information retrieval.
As Omnivore sunsets its services, users have several compelling alternatives to choose from, each offering unique strengths for different reading workflows and preferences.
Act before the November 2024 deadline to ensure a smooth transition. While no single platform perfectly replicates Omnivore's feature set, the evolving read-it-later app landscape continues to innovate, promising more sophisticated solutions for digital readers in the future.
Want to supercharge your productivity?
Unlock the full potential of Notion & Obsidian with our plugins.
